The Trump Administration, led by the Justice Department, is preparing to denounce America’s midterm elections, claiming “massive” voter fraud, usually allegations of voting by non-citizens. We need to be prepared to respond.
In general, progressives seek to simplify and improve the accuracy of voter registration and to make voting more convenient. Leaders on the far right try to make it harder for eligible Americans to register and vote. Your argument is based on freedom, patriotism, and modernizing our voting systems. Their argument is based on an imagined fear of voter fraud.
When you’re talking about voting systems, begin with a statement of your values.
Say… In America, the right to vote is a fundamental freedom. And because we are the world’s leading democracy, our election system ought to be completely free, fair, and accessible.
In other words, put the discussion in context. When talking about voting, progressives have two great advantages that are too rarely used by our side:
First, the most popular and powerful value in political debate is freedom. Use it for this issue. If voting is understood as a basic right like freedom of speech, then it must be protected. None of our freedoms should be limited without an overriding reason, and in this case, none exists. If you can win the frame that voting is a fundamental freedom, you’ll ultimately win the argument.
Second, Americans are (mostly) proud of American democracy, and an appeal to that patriotism helps persuade them.
So, how do we deal with lies about voter fraud?
In the real world, if someone tries to cast a ballot by impersonating an eligible voter or tries to manipulate voting numbers, that’s a crime punishable by years in prison. Because the penalty is so severe, this crime almost never happens. Out of millions of votes cast, only a handful are cast by people who shouldn’t have, and usually it was caused by some government agency wrongly telling such a person they have the right to vote. Wrongful voting is so rare that it never comes close to changing the results of an election.
The problem is that far-right media has convinced many Americans that voter fraud exists. The best messaging advice is to acknowledge the importance of protecting the integrity of our elections, argue that voting is the most basic right in a democracy, and push the debate toward making elections free, fair, and accessible. For example, when arguing against voter ID legislation, appeal to freedom and patriotism, and then:
Say… Protecting election integrity is essential. But we cannot protect elections by obstructing American citizens’ freedom to vote. To deny freedom is to subvert our nation’s most fundamental principle, it’s unAmerican.
Again, lean heavily on the shared value of freedom. Freedom is the most powerful word in American politics.
Finally, talk about the courts.
Say… Ultimately, according to our Constitution, the courts will decide any legal claims against an election. However, the Trump Administration and, previously, the Trump campaign, have filed lawsuits many dozens of times against election results and they have never been successful — because courts of law require facts not accusations. Trump’s attacks on this election will fail because they are grounded in fiction.
Of course, do not underestimate the difficulty of the progressive argument. Be mindful of Americans’ beliefs and use their own values to win them over.