When and how should you argue on social media?

Posted on February 12, 2020

If you never have a social media “friend” who posts something false, then you don’t have to read this column. For the rest of us, what should you do when you see lies or particularly egregious exaggerations or fallacies about political issues, officeholders or candidates?

Usually you should ignore them.

People hate to be told they are wrong and you will trigger particularly negative emotions by calling the writer out in front of their social media “friends.”

As we explain in PLI’s messaging guide, Voicing Our Values, people seek out information that conforms to what they already believe and reject information that disproves those assumptions. This is called “confirmation bias.”

In response to evidence that challenges those beliefs, people will stop listening and disengage from rational conversation. In fact, when you attack preexisting beliefs, not only are your arguments rejected, but it tends to deepen such people’s emotional attachment to false ideas.

So, you will almost always do no good in trying to change the writer’s mind. She or he will likely hold onto lies even more strongly and you may damage a friendship in the process.

Nevertheless, there are two factors that suggest we should sometimes point out political lies on social media. First, while we won’t persuade the writer, we may persuade other readers. Second, the 2020 elections will be so close that changing the minds of just a tiny percentage of Americans may do a world of good.

The most obvious situation where we can and should step in and make a (small) difference is when a “friend” reposts a meme that is clearly false. Unfortunately, we must expect a thunderstorm of Internet lies, gradually increasing from now until Labor Day, when social media falsehoods will probably outnumber truths. There will be photoshopped photos, doctored videos, and outrageous claims that have long been debunked.

These lies will rain down from every direction, including organized hate groups, astroturf efforts financed by billionaires, and foreign agents—certainly from Russia, but also probably from China, Saudi Arabia, and even Israel.

Your best tactic will be to address not the writer but the facts, and the best response will be to hyperlink to objective proof that the meme is untrue—like Snopes, Politifact, FactCheck.org, or Fact Checkers at AP, NPR, CNN or the Washington Post. In some cases, the best tactic will be to point out that the source of the meme is a Russian or a hate group.

Do not expect your efforts to be appreciated! And don’t expect that they will change many minds. They won’t.

But so much is at stake this year. So few voters will tilt the result one way or another. Some well-placed, sparsely written, cool-headed and hyperlinked comments can make a difference. It’s worth the effort.

 

SHARE

How to rebut logical fallacies in the impeachment debate

Posted on January 30, 2020

Progressives have gotten so used to hearing bald-faced lies that perhaps we have become a little less ready to recognize which rhetorical tricks are being used against us. Let us consider five of the...

SHARE

How did the American economy become a disgrace?

Posted on January 15, 2020

The question is not whether the economy is operating well, or even adequately, for the most Americans. The question is, what happened over the years to make it such an abysmal failure? By failure,...

SHARE

All Politics Is Local—about the PLI Conference

Posted on January 1, 2020

Except from the book by Meaghan Winter (pages 181-182) I first saw Leslie Herod at work in the summer of 2017, when she appeared on a panel at a conference sponsored by the Public Leadership Institute—a...

SHARE

All Politics Is Local: Why Progressives Must Fight for the States

Posted on December 18, 2019

Except from the book by Meaghan Winter (pages 20-21) Many of the foot soldiers advocating for social change today are not explicitly working within the party structures; they are community groups, advocacy organizations, lobbying...

SHARE

For average American’s it’s still the economy, stupid!

Posted on December 4, 2019

James Carville famously made economics central to Bill Clinton’s 1992 presidential campaign, insisting “It’s the economy, stupid!” The mainstream media thinks that the American economy is roaring and that will help GOP campaigns. But...

SHARE

What’s 2020 about? Perhaps our children.

Posted on November 20, 2019

Any political or policy campaign is fundamentally about persuading people that you, or your cause, are “on their side.” Progressive activists tend to respond that, sure, we’re going to show Americans that we are...

SHARE

Ten popular measures for 2020

Posted on November 6, 2019

Progressives should decide where they stand on issues based on values, not on polls. At the same time, it is smart politics to lift up our more popular issues. The most important thing is...

SHARE

The three most basic rules of politics

Posted on October 24, 2019

The purpose of political action is to change public policy. Those of us who are involved in politics and policy are familiar with the legislative and electoral processes. But, do progressives really understand what...

SHARE

Why does the media repeat lies?

Posted on October 9, 2019

In 1997, legendary Washington Post editor Ben Bradlee gave a speech about truth and lies in politics. He explained that newspapers “don’t tell the truth” when they (a) don’t know the truth, (b) quote someone who is...

SHARE