IdeaLog
Don’t say “woke” and other idiocy
Posted on March 22, 2023
Here we go again. The rightwing adopts absurd messaging, it dominates the conversation for a time, and then their leaders move on to other, similar absurdities. The directors of the rightwing noise machine know what they’re doing, but do you?
In his classic book “Don’t Think of an Elephant,” George Lakoff wrote:
When we negate a frame, we evoke the frame. Richard Nixon found that out the hard way. While under pressure to resign during the Watergate scandal, Nixon addressed the nation on TV. He stood before the nation and said, “I am not a crook.” And everybody thought about him as a crook. That gives us a basic principle for framing, for when you are arguing against the other side: Do not use their language. Their language picks out a frame—and it won’t be the frame you want.
So, for heaven’s sake, stop repeating the latest rightwing language. Don’t repeat, “woke” or “Critical Race Theory” or “ESG” or “cancel culture” or “culture war” or “groomer.” They’re all stupid but effective ways to deflect a discussion of politics and public policy away from real, rational issues, like wages, benefits, debt, healthcare and the environment to vague, emotional battle-cries.
If there is one thing that we at the Public Leadership Institute urge the most, it is to be proactive not reactive. Decide how you want to frame the debate and then adopt a series of messages and push a series of policies that evoke that frame. Reject the rightwing language and inject your own.
Does that mean to ignore the rightwing when they say “woke”? Pretty much, yes.
One way to respond is something like: “That’s crazy. How does that help people in [insert your state/city/county]? How does that [insert three issues like—fix our roads, improve our healthcare, or protect our quality of life]? This is what’s important: [insert your overall message like—how do we get things done for our communities]?”
If you’re in circumstances where you believe you have to answer about “woke,” say “This is nonsense. Give me real examples and we can discuss those.” Ignore the vague larger “issue” and confine yourself to the necessarily-bigoted examples. Then, as quickly as possible, pivot the discussion away from those and to your proactive message frame.
Why are you scared of “woke,” anyway? This language is aimed squarely at the conspiracy theory-believing base. You will never get their support. Ignore them. At the same time, this kind of language alienates persuadable general election voters.
Consider a recent USA Today/Ipsos poll. When Americans were asked “Thinking about what it means to be woke, which of the following comes closest to your view, even if neither is exactly right?” 56 percent answered “To be informed, educated on, and aware of social injustices” (that is, 78 percent of Democrats, 51 percent of Independents, and 37 percent of Republicans), while only 39 percent answered “To be overly politically correct and police others’ words” (that is, 18 percent of Democrats, 45 percent of Independents, and 56 percent of Republicans).
You see, Ron DeSantis isn’t emphasizing the word “woke” to win the general election, it is to win the Republican primaries.
The same poll also casts light on the details of the “woke” attack. It found that, contrary to the rightwing messaging, 72 percent of Americans (89 percent of Democrats, 82 percent of Independents, and 46 percent of Republicans) support “Teaching the ongoing effects of slavery and racism in the United States in public schools.” And only 21 percent of Americans support “State governments passing laws that ban certain books from school classrooms and libraries.” 70 percent of Democrats and even 44 percent of Republicans “strongly oppose” such book bans.
Rightwing codewords are shortcuts allowing politicians and pundits to engage in ignorant bigotry without being specific. CRT and BLM are essentially substitutes for the n-word. Groomer is mostly a substitute for the f-word. Soros means evil Jewish people. And to their base, “woke” simply means liberal.
When you feel like you should explain the reality of these codewords to the MAGA people, just snap out of it.
For truth, not triangulation, on crime
Posted on March 9, 2023
With the blessing of President Biden, most Democrats in the U.S. Senate joined Republicans in voting to overturn the District of Columbia’s recodification of local criminal laws. This is because the Administration “believes criticism...
The imminent threat of Christian nationalism
Posted on February 22, 2023
PRRI (Public Religion Research Institute) recently published a groundbreaking poll with analysis entitled “Understanding the Threat of Christian Nationalism to American Democracy and Culture.” The topline of the PRRI/Brookings poll received considerable coverage by...
This Big Lie is more dangerous than the one about the 2020 election
Posted on February 8, 2023
Most Republicans now believe that average Democrats are “extreme,” “immoral” and “dishonest.” This results from years of right-wing propaganda. Rank-and-file conservatives now live in a carefully curated alternate reality. According to Pew Research, 72...
Five more new model bills for 2023
Posted on January 25, 2023
Our 2023 Progressive Agenda for the States & Localities recommends 50 bills for this year, many of them brand new. Our last IdeaLog suggested five innovative model bills on a variety of subjects. Here...
Five new model bills for 2023
Posted on January 11, 2023
Our 2023 Progressive Agenda for the States & Localities recommends 50 bills for this year, many of them brand new. Here are five innovative model bills on a variety of subjects. Fight back against...
Five lessons of the 2022 midterm election
Posted on December 14, 2022
Was 2022 a turnout election? Which groups are trending toward one of the parties? How important was inflation? Do voters even like the Democratic Party? In short, what mattered to voters in the midterms?...
Ballot initiatives are trending progressive
Posted on November 30, 2022
Progressive ballot measures did quite well in 2022. In contrast, before the last decade or so, conservatives largely dominated ballot measures, using them to energize their base with an anti-tax, anti-labor and anti-LGBT agenda....
Start planning abortion rights ballot measures for 2024
Posted on November 16, 2022
There were six state referenda on abortion this year (CA, KS, KY, MI, MT, VT) and abortion rights won all of them. Proactive ballot measures not only enshrine good laws, they drive turnout and...
2022 elections come down to turnout
Posted on November 2, 2022
The 2022 elections will be decided by voter turnout, just like the elections of 2016, 2018, 2020 and 2021. The polls suggest that the battle for control of the U.S. Senate is razor-close, and...