PLI in Rewire on Justice Kennedy’s retirement

Posted on June 29, 2018

Justice Kennedy’s Retirement Could Leave Abortion Rights Up to State Lawmakers

 Lauren Holter

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy’s retirement could mean the end of Roe v. Wade if President Donald Trump holds true to his promise to appoint justices willing to overturn the ruling that guaranteed the right to legal abortion. Doing so could leave abortion access in the hands of individual states—and many are poised to ban the procedure entirely.

“Whether women have a right to abortion will depend on which state they live in,” said Caroline Mala Corbin, professor of law at the University of Miami. “The right to abortion doesn’t vanish, it just is up to the states.”

Every major U.S. Supreme Court abortion decision in the past 40 years has come down to a 5-4 vote. Because Kennedy often acted as the swing vote in favor of preserving legal abortion, legal experts agree that a more conservative court would likely rule against abortion when a relevant case reaches the bench.

Even with Roe v. Wade intact, states have heavily restricted when and where someone can terminate a pregnancy. And if that federal protection were to disappear, 23 states would be at risk of losing the right to an abortion completely, according to the Center for Reproductive Rights.

“In a lot of ways, Roe has been hanging by a thread for at least 20 years,” said Jennifer Lawless, director of the Women and Politics Institute and a professor of government at American University. “It’s almost a foregone conclusion that as soon as the court has the opportunity they’ll overturn Roe, and the decision will go back to the states.”

Four states are already prepared to outlaw abortion the minute Roe falls. Legislators in Louisiana, Mississippi, North Dakota, and South Dakota have passed trigger laws that would effectively ban abortion without any further legislative action. Legal experts told Rewire.News that more states eager to ban abortion will likely start taking action following Kennedy’s departure.

Thirteen states have pre-Roe bans on the books that could be reinstated (Louisiana has both a trigger law and a pre-Roeban). In states where these bans were never deemed unconstitutional, they could immediately spring into effect. But in states where a court previously blocked the ban, legislators must petition to have that decision overruled.

Pro-choice advocates want to see those pre-Roe bans removed, but some Democratic lawmakers’ efforts have been unsuccessful. A bill in Rhode Island aiming to codify abortion rights into state law has twice failed to reach a vote. However, Kennedy’s retirement has reignited the state legislature’s debate, the Providence Journal reports.

Meanwhile, eight states have laws that explicitly protect the right to legal abortion, according to the Guttmacher Institute, and states such as New York have stalled on similar laws.

If pro-choice advocates don’t prepare for the absence of Roe at the state level by passing more laws guaranteeing the right to abortion and wiping out conservative majorities in state legislatures, said Gloria Totten, president of the Public Leadership Institute, “we will be missing a really key part of what needs to happen.”

Because state legislatures hold so much power, thinking about reproductive rights when voting in November “takes on new meaning and new significance,” Lawless said. “It’s possible that state legislative candidates would be successful highlighting that the stakes have changed and there’s now a high likely that there won’t be some broad federal protection.”

The record number of women running for office this year—the majority of whom are Democrats—has the potential to change the political landscape across the country, which could, in turn, change the landscape of abortion laws. Even though states could eventually determine the legal status of abortion within their own borders, a so-called “blue wave” would increase the likelihood that more states would protect the right to abortion.

Kelly Baden, director of reproductive rights for the State Innovation Exchange, believes there will be opportunities to guarantee abortion remains legal in more states before the downfall of Roe.

“I am optimistic that there will be enough of a public outcry and enough of a new crop of legislators with the political will to take this issue on,” Baden said.


PLI quoted on Justice Kennedy’s retirement

Posted on

Justice Kennedy’s Retirement Could Have Big Implications For Abortion Rights In Texas By ASHLEY LOPEZ • JUN 28, 2018 Abortion rights advocates in Texas say the retirement of Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy raises the stakes for...


PLI quoted in Rewire about protecting Roe

Posted on March 22, 2018

New York Could Become the Latest State to Solidify ‘Roe’ Protections as Trump Looms by Auditi Guha The New York State Assembly passed the Reproductive Health Act passed last week, the latest step in a nationwide effort by...


PLI quoted in New York Times story on stun cuffs

Posted on March 12, 2018

To Control Inmates, Some Counties Try the Threat of Electric Shock by Jacey Fortin Many of the electric shock devices used by law enforcement are meant to be out of sight, but every once in...


Letter to the Editor in the New York Times

Posted on February 11, 2018

In the Sunday New York Times To the Editor: We should not encourage lawmakers to decide where they stand on critical issues based on political expediency. Yet David Brooks tells Democrats that they should...


Turning the Tables on the Abortion Fight

Posted on February 6, 2018

by Gloria Totten in Common Dreams When it comes to healthcare, it is only women and women’s health that is legislated so forcefully. Forty five years after the Supreme Court’s Roe v. Wade decision...


45 Years After ‘Roe’: How to Turn Resistance Into Victory

Posted on January 22, 2018

Rewire by Gloria Totten The momentum from the Women’s March can’t stop on Election Day. As I stood in the middle of Boston Common last year, taking part in one of many Women’s March...


Lawmakers in 25 States Join Nationwide Effort to Protect Roe v. Wade

Posted on

Common Dreams Abortion rights advocates commemorate the 45th Anniversary of the Roe decision WASHINGTON – Lawmakers from 25 states and 3 localities have joined together to introduce proactive legislation to protect women’s fundamental right...


The Untold Story of the Roe v. Wade Anniversary

Posted on

OurFuture and Common Dreams by Gloria Totten Today – January 22 – is the 45th anniversary of the Supreme Court ruling in Roe v. Wade, which recognized abortion as a constitutional right. This year, as in...


Seven Questions on Progressive Strategy

Posted on January 18, 2018

7 Questions with Bernie Horn on Progressive Campaign Strategy The Campaign Workshop Blog Bernie Horn of the Public Leadership Institute shares his insight on progressive messaging and campaign strategy. Bernie Horn is the Senior...